The Lost Fort
My Travel and History Blog, Focussing mostly on Roman and Mediaeval Times
Feudalism 101 (Part 2)
Carolingian Times (8th-10h centuries)
Subsequently, the oath of obedience changed into an oath of fealty, and therewith the system of entourage into the genuine feudal system.
Not all the retainers could live at the court, so they were given a piece of land as beneficium (French fief), and they were only called into service on special occassions. The dependence of the vassals towards their lord was lessened, at the same time the social status of the vasalls developed into membership of a special group with increasingly high standing that would become the knights. A disadvantage of this development resulted in the king and the lords somewhat losing the grip on their vasalls.
During the reign of Charlemagne, feudality developed into a veritable system by uniting the originally independent institutions of the personal bound by commendation and the landloan of the beneficium. Vassalage thus became the prerequisite for receiving a beneficium. The act of making a vasall was formalized: the first step was the commendation or manumission ('handgang' - the vasall put his hands into the hands of the lord), followed by an oath of fealty. Touching of a reliquar was also often part of it.
The importance of the oath was enhanced the moment the institution of the antrustiones went into decline. A possible reason for this was the fact that the oath was legally binding for both parties and it could only take part between freeborn men. It thus gave a counterweight to the act of the commendation that stressed the dependant situation of the vasall. Successively, vassalage became acceptable even for persons of high standing.
Obedience was no longer neccesarily included in the oath formula. "By this oath I promise to be faithful to my lord, the very pious Emperor Charles, as according to custom and right a vasall owns faith towards his lord, to guard his realm and protect his rights. And I will keep this my sworn oath henceforth as is in my power, and may God, Creator of heaven and earth, and these holy relics help me." (1) Often the oath of fealty is defined in a 'negative' way: not to do anything that may give harm or disadvantage to the lord, "...to ensure the king by an oath of fidelity not to do anything against his life and his body, and not to take him prisoner to his disadvantage..." (2) The lord, too, had duties towards his vasalls, besides fidelity from his side it was mostly protection in form of military aid in case the vasall was attacked, and maintenance, fe. by giving him a beneficium. In addition to the afore mentioned fidelty, the vasall owed his lord consilium et auxilium, ie. he had to visit his lord on days of council and judgement and function as an advisor. Auxilium meant military aid as a mounted knight, together with his retainers, if he had; but it also could involve payment of ransom, or giving financial support in case of great celebrations such as marriage. High standing vasalls of a king could be asked to bring 500 or 1000 warriors to a war, part of them fully equipped kinghts. Therefore, vassalty was mostly a military institution.
Commendation and oath-taking both founded the personal relationship between vasall and lord, and a contract made in that way could not be broken or annulated save by the death of one of the parties. Later on, failure of one of the parties to keep the mutual promise of succour by the vasall and protection by the lord could also lead to annulation of the feudal bond. We have to keep in mind that personal bonds were the only way to somewhat regulate the misuse of power in a society without a 'modern' political system of legislative and courts of justice. Added to this, religion in Mediaeval society had a very strong influence and oath-breaking was considered as a major sacrilege leading directly towards condamnation.
Third part of the ceremony of making a vasall was the so-called investiture: the vasall was given the right over his beneficium by handing over of a symbolic object, fe. a staff. The sequence and importance ot the three elements of commendation, oath, and investiture changed within time.
Originally, the beneficium fell back to the lord after the vasall died. But the heirs of a vasall were, of course, interested in keeping the fief. Often the lord agreed to this and the usual way was to reenact the whole ceremony to make the new bond legal. In the second half of the 9th century heritage became the accepted way of transferring a fief.
The feudal pyramid - that means the system of lesser lords bound to dukes and counts, and these bound to the king - was weakened by the fact that an increasing number of minor vasalls and subsequently even the higher ones gave their alliance to several lords for different fiefs. This resulted in a lessened bond towards the king, the oath-taking became a mere formality. At the end of the millenium the feudal system was close to a collapse, a development accelerated by the weakening of the position of the king during the late Carolingian period (there were often several sons fighting over the heritage and the lands). But still the value of the oath had some effect and kept the feudal system and with it the empire from collapsing.
Footnotes
(1) Annales Regni Francorum 802
(2) Actes des comtes de Flandre; part of the oath sworn by Count Robert II of Flanders to King Henry I of England in 1101
Picture: Roland swearing fealty to Charlemagne, from the mss. of a chanson de geste - Public Domain (could not find out which particular manuscript)
Feudalism 101 (Part 1)
Merovingian Times (5th-8th centuries)
"Because it is well known to everyone that I have no food and no clothes, I have prayed to your compassion and I have of my free will decided to give myself into your protection, or to commend myself to you. And I have done this; it shall be that way that you will give me food and clothes and support me in the measure as I will serve you and therewith earn your support. Until my death I am obliged to serve you and to obey you as I may as a freeborn man, and during my life I cannot withdraw from your power and protection, but I will remain in your power and protection as long as I live." (1) This formula is a rare written example for a process which usually was staged orally and by the use of symbolic gestures. The contract of commendation was concluded between two persons and ended with the death of one of the parties. It is important to note that the duties of the commendent might not interfere with his rights and dignity as a freeborn man.
Pacts between free men of lower social status and men of power have already existed in Merovingian times, and I suppose they may have existed even earlier albeit there's no proof. Roman sources did not care how exactly the relationship between fe. Arminius and his retainers, if he had such, was defined.
Those pacts were based upon service from the one side, and protection from the other side, the patrocinium. The relation between them was hierarchical, power on one side, obedience on the other. Especially kings could thus attract men, and in Merovingian times these royal retainers were called antrustiones. They formed a special sort of personal guard with a number of privileges. For example, if any of them was killed in a fight, his relatives got a higher weregild than for a non-member (2). This special status the group had in common with the Old Norse hirð, only the latter organisation lasted until the 13th century. The Merovingian antrustiones fell into decline when the Carolingian familiy rose to kingship in the 8th century.
The contract does not specify the duties of the vassal, nor the way the protection of the lord was carried out. Nor is it clear whether the commendation in these early times necessarily involved an oath of fealty, or a symbolic gesture like the manumission. But both are occasionally mentioned concerning the antrustiones (3)
The lord could keep the commendent at his court, but he could also give him a piece of his land to live upon. This was called tenure in case it was given as a loan, and usually the tenant had to pay taxes or tithes. But the lord could also give the land under more favourable conditions like tax exemption as a beneficium (4). In Merovingian times the patrocinium, based upon obedience and service from the commendent (sometimes called vassus) and protection by the lord, and the gift of a beneficium were separate institutions. That changed in Carolingian times when vassalty and beneficium became connected. (5)
Footnotes
(1) Taken from the Formulae Turonensis, No. 43. Edition: MG Formulae Merovingici et Karolini Aevi. ed. by K. Zeumer, p. 158. The formula dates from the beginning of the 8th century, but the form of it goes back to an old tradition (Ganshof, p. 4).
(2) It is not clear whether the members of the antrustiones were connected in a form of co-operative among each other (as it was the case in the hirð), or whether they as vassals of the king only were bound to him; Althoff, p. 139.
(3) Ganshof, p. 7. An example for the act in: De regis antrustione, in: Marciulfi Formulae 1.18, ed. Zeumer).
(4) The word beneficium is often used in the chartes and documents from the Merovingian times onward (Ganshof, p. 9).
(5) The word vasall (Latin vassus or vassallus) is used from the 8th century onwards. It might go back to the Celtic gwas = servant (Schulze, p. 58), but there is no absolute proof for this assumption.
Literature
Gerd Althoff. Verwandte, Freunde und Getreue - Zum politischen Stellenwert der Grupppenbindungen im früheren Mittelalter. Darmstadt 1990 (Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft)Karl-Heinz Bender. König und Vasall. Untersuchungen zur Chanson de geste des XII. Jahrhunderts, Heidelberg, 1967 (=Studia Romanica 13)James Campbell. The Anglo-Saxon State (selected essays). London and New York, 2000Jean Favier. Histoire de France vol. II. Le temps de principautés - De l'an mil a 1515. Paris, 1984François Louis Ganshof. Qu'est-ce que la féodalité? Bruxelles, 1944, 3rd and reworked ed. 1957 (that book still is a standard work)Michael Heintze. König, Held und Sippe - Untersuchungen zur Chanson de geste des 13 und 14. Jahrhunderts und ihrer Zyklenbildung. Studia Romanica 76, Heidelberg 1991John Le Patourel. Feudal Empires, Norman and Plantagenet (selected essays). London, 1984Erich Köhler. Conseil des barons et jugement des barons: Epische Fatalität und Feudalrecht im altfranzösischen Rolandslied. In: H. Krauß (ed.) Altfranzösische Epik, Darmstadt 1978, S. 368-412François Neveux. La Normandie: des ducs aux rois, Xe - XIIe siècle. Rennes, 1998Pierre Riché. Les Carolingiens - Une famille qui fit l'Europe. Paris, 1983Hans K. Schulze. Grundstrukturen der Verfassung im Mittelalter, Band 1: Stammesverband, Gefolgschaft, Lehnswesen, Grundherrschaft. Stuttgart, Berlin, Köln 1985Karl Ferdinand Werner. Die Ursprünge Frankreichs bis zum Jahr 1000. München, 1995 (1st edition 1984)
Ausonius' Mosella
Salve, amnis odorifero iuga vitea consite baccho,
consite gramineas amnis viridissime ripas!
naviger ut pelagus, devexas pronus in undas
ut fluvius, vitreoque lacus imitate profundo.
Thus says the poet Decimus Magnus Ausonius (310-395 AD) in his Mosella. Ausonius was born in Bordeaux (Burdigala, Gaul); poet, wine-lover, teacher of the young emperor-to-be Gratian, and obviously a bit of a traveller since his poem Mosella describes a journey along the river.
The viridissime ripas of the Moselle
I attempted a translation albeit I suck at Latin, lol:
A complete Latin version can be found here.
Greetings, river, framed by perfumed vineyard-covered hills,
Framed by grass; river of greenest shores.
Your strong waters carry ships, flowing in easy waves
Along the stream, and a glittering lake your depths emulate.
I wish I had known the text when I traveled there. The images Ausonius evokes respond to what I did experience on my Moselle cruise in the evening.
The Roman bridge across the Moselle in the evening haze
Quis color ille vadis, seras cum propulit umbras
Hesperus et viridi perfudit monte Mosellam.
tota natant crispis iuga motibus et tremit absens
pampinus et vitreis vindemia turget in undis.
adnumerat virides derisus navita vites,
navita caudiceo fluitans super aequora lembo,
per medium, qua sese amni confundit imago
collis et umbrarum confinia conserit amnis.
Evening at the Moselle
What colour are the waters when the Evening Star
Brings shadows of night, and green mountains fill the Moselle.
Hilltops swim in rippling waters, and trembles
The distant vine and grapes swell in crystal waves.
The boatsman counts mocking green vines
As he lets his boat drift by on the surface.
In the middle, where the river confounds its own image
With hills and shadows, lines blur in the water.
The Lost Fort is a travel and history blog based on my journeys in Germany, the UK, Scandinavia, and central / eastern Europe. It includes virtual town and castle tours with a focus on history, museum visits, hiking tours, and essays on Roman and Mediaeval history, illustrated with my own photos.
This blog is non-commercial.
All texts and photos (if no other copyright is noted) are copyright of Gabriele Campbell.
GDPR Privacy Policy

- Name: Gabriele Campbell
- Location: Goettingen, Germany
I'm a blogger from Germany with a MA in Literature and History which doesn't pay my bills, so I use it to research blogposts instead. I'm interested in everything Roman and Mediaeval, avid reader and sometimes writer, opera enthusiast, traveller with a liking for foreign languages and odd rocks, photographer, and tea aficionado. And an old-fashioned blogger who still hasn't got an Instagram account.
(See here for Archives for mobile devices)
View my complete profile
Anchor links lead to the respective sub-category in the sidebar
Roman Remains
- Germany
- Belgium and France
- Great Britain
Mediaeval and Other Places
- Germany
- England
- Scotland
- Wales
- Denmark
- Norway
- Sweden
- Finland
- Russia
- Estonia
- Latvia
- Lithuania
- Poland
- Czechia
- Belgium
- Luxembourg
- France
Hiking Tours and Cruises
- Germany
- United Kingdom
- Scandinavia
- Baltic Sea
Roman Remains
Germany
Traces of a Failed Conquest
Romans at Lippe and Ems
Roman Exhibitions, Haltern am See
Varus Statue, Haltern am See
Romans at the Weser
The Roman Camp at Hedemünden
The Limes and its Forts
Aalen
The Cavalry Fort - Barracks
Osterburken
The Discovery
The Cohort castellum
The Annex Fort
The Garrisons
Saalburg
Introduction
Main Gate
Shrine of the Standards
Temples and Memorials
Mithras Altars in Germania
Romans at Rhine and Moselle
The Villa Rustica in Wachenheim
Introduction
Baths and Toilets
The Cellar
Roman villae at the Moselle
The Villa Urbana in Longuich
Roman Towns
Augusta Treverorum (Trier)
The Amphitheatre
The Aula Palatina
The Imperial Baths
The Porta Nigra
The Roman Bridge
Baudobriga (Boppard)
From Settlement to Fortress
Colonia Ulpia Traiana (Xanten)
History of the Town
The Amphitheatre in Birten
Moguntiacum (Mainz)
The Temple of Isis and Mater Magna
Belgium and France
Roman Towns
Atuatuca Tungrorum (Tongeren)
Roman Remains in Tongeren
Great Britain
Frontiers and Fortifications
The Hadrian's Wall
Introduction
Building the Wall
Wall Forts - Banna (Birdoswald)
The Dark Age Timber Halls
Wall Forts - Segedunum (Wallsend)
Museum, Viewing Tower and Foundations
The Baths
Signal Stations
The Signal Station at Scarborough
Temples and Memorials
The Mithraeum of Brocolita
A Roman Memorial Stone
Roman Towns
Eboracum (York)
Bath in the Fortress
Multiangular Tower
The Romans in Wales
Roman Forts - Isca (Caerleon)
The Amphitheatre
The Baths in the Legionary Fort
Mediaeval and Other Places
Germany
- Towns
- Castles
- Abbeys and Churches
- Reconstructed Sites / Museums
Towns
Braunschweig
Medieaval Braunschweig
Lion Benches in the Castle Square
The Quadriga
Erfurt
Mediaeval Erfurt
Goslar
Mediaeval Goslar
The Chapel in the Klus Rock
Lübeck
St. Mary's Church, Introduction
Magdeburg
Magdeburg Cathedral
St.Mary's Abbey - An Austere Archbishop
St.Mary's Abbey - Reformation to Reunion
Paderborn
Mediaeval Paderborn
Quedlinburg
Mediaeval Quedlinburg
The Chapter Church
Speyer
The Cathedral: Architecture
Cathedral: Richard Lionheart in Speyer
Jewish Ritual Bath
Stralsund
The Harbour
Wismar
The Old Harbour
Xanten
Mediaeval Xanten
The Gothic House
Collected Posts about Towns
Towns in Thuringia
Heiligenstadt
Treffurt
Castles
Brandenburg (Thuringia)
The Double Castle
Role of the Castle in Thuringian History
Coburg Fortress (Bavaria)
The History of the Fortress
The Architecture
Ebersburg (Harz Mountains)
Power Base of the Thuringian Landgraves
The Marshals of Ebersburg
The Architecture
Hanstein (Thuringia)
Introduction
Otto of Northeim
Heinrich the Lion and Otto IV
The Next Generations
Hardenberg (Lower Saxony)
Introduction
Hardenberg Castle Gardens
Harzburg (Harz Mountains)
The Harzburg and Otto IV
Hohnstein (Harz Mountains)
Origins of the Counts of Hohnstein
The Family Between Welfen and Staufen
A Time of Feuds (14th-15th century)
Kugelsburg (Hessia)
The Counts of Everstein
Troubled Times
War and Decline
Plesse (Lower Saxony)
Rise and Fall of the Counts of Winzenburg
The Lords of Plesse
Architecture / Decline and Rediscovery
Regenstein (Harz Mountains)
Introduction
The Time of Henry the Lion
Scharzfels (Harz Mountains)
Introduction
History
Wartburg (Thuringia)
A Virtual Tour
Weidelsburg (Hessia)
The History of the Castle
The Architecture
The Castle After the Restoration
Collected Posts about Castles
Castles in the Harz Mountains
Stapelburg
Stauffenburg
Castles in Northern Hessia
Grebenstein
Reichenbach
Sichelnstein
Sababurg and Trendelburg
Castles in Lower Saxony
Adelebsen Castle: The Keep
Grubenhagen: A Border Castle
Hardeg Castle: The Great Hall
Salzderhelden: A Welfen Seat
Castles at the Weser
Bramburg: River Reivers
Krukenburg: Castle and Chapel
Castle Polle: An Everstein Seat
Castles in Thuringia
A Collection of some Castles
Altenstein at the Werra
Castle Normanstein: Introduction
Castle Scharfenstein
Abbeys and Churches
Bursfelde Abbey
The Early History
Helmarshausen Monastery
Remains of the Monastery
The Gospels of Heinrich the Lion
Königslutter Cathedral
The Exterior Decorations
Lippoldsberg Abbey
The Early History
The Interior of the Church
Walkenried Monastery
From Monastery to Museum
Collected Posts about Churches
Early Mediaeval Churches
Göllingen Monastery: Traces of Byzantine Architecture
Lorsch Abbey: The Carolingian Gate Hall
Churches in the Harz Mountains
Pöhlde Monastery: The Remaining Church
Stave Church in Hahnenklee
Steinkirche (Scharzfeld): Development of the Cave Church
Churches in Lower Saxony
Wiebrechtshausen: Nunnery and Ducal Burial
Churches at the Weser
Fredelsloh Chapter Church
Vernawahlshausen: Mediaeval Murals
Reconstructed Sites / Museums
Stone Settings and Tombs
Neolithic Burials in the Everstorf Forest and on Rugia
Open Air Museums
European Bread Museum, Ebergötzen
Open Air Museum Oerlinghausen
Palatine Seat Tilleda
The Defenses
Viking Settlement Haithabu
Haithabu and the Archaeological Museum Schleswig
The Nydam Ship
Post-Mediaeval Sites
Historical Guns, Coburg Fortress
Vintage Car Museum, Wolfsburg
England
Towns
Chester
Roman and Medieaval Chester
Hexham
The Abbey - Introduction
The Old Gaol
York
Clifford Tower
The Guild Hall
The Minster - Architecture
Monk Bar Gate and Richard III Museum
Museum Gardens
The Old Town
Along the Ouse River
Castles
Alnwick
Malcolm III and the First Battle of Alnwick
Carlisle
Introduction
Henry II and William of Scotland
Edward I to Edward III
Richmond
From the Conquest to King John
From Henry III to the Tudors
The Architecture
Scarborough
From the Romans to the Tudors
From the Civil War to the Present
The Architecture
Scotland
Towns
Edinburgh
Views from the Castle
Stirling
The Wallace Monument
Castles
Doune
A Virtual Tour of the Castle
The Early Stewart Kings
Royal Dower House, and Decline
Duart
Guarding the Sound of Mull
Dunstaffnage
An Ancient MacDougall Stronghold
The Wars of Independence
The Campbells Are Coming
Dunstaffnage Chapel
Stirling
Robert the Bruce and Stirling Castle
Abbeys and Churches
Inchcolm Abbey
Arriving at Inchcolm
Other Historical Sites
Neolithic Orkney
Ring of Brodgar
Skara Brae
Brochs and Cairns
Clava Cairns
The Brochs of Gurness and Midhowe - Introduction
Picts and Dalriatans
Dunadd Hill Fort
Staffa
Wales
Towns
Aberystwyth
Castle and Coast
Caerleon
The Ffwrwm
Conwy
The Smallest House in Great Britain
Castles
Beaumaris
The Historical Context
The Architecture
Caernarfon
Master James of St.George
The Castle Kitchens
Cardiff
From the Romans to the Victorians
Chepstow
Beginnings unto Bigod
From Edward II to the Tudors
Civil War, Restoration, and Aftermath
Conwy
The History of the Castle
The Architecture
Criccieth
Llywelyn's Buildings
King Edward's Buildings
Manorbier
The Pleasantest Spot in Wales
Pembroke
Pembroke Pictures
The Caves Under the Castle
Denmark
Towns
Copenhagen
To come
Norway
Towns
Oslo
The Fram Museum in Oslo
Castles and Fortresses
Arkershus Fortress in Oslo
Introduction
Akershus at the Time of King Håkon V
Architectural Development
Vardøhus Fortress
Defending the North for Centuries
Sweden
Towns
Stockholm
The Vasa Museum
Historical Landscapes
Gotland
Gnisvärd Ship Setting
Finland
Towns
Porvoo
Mediaeval Porvoo
Russia
Towns
St. Petersburg
Isaac's Cathedral
Smolny Cathedral
Impressions from the The Neva River
Estonia
Towns
Tallinn
The History of Mediaeval Tallinn
Latvia
Towns
Riga
The History of Mediaeval Riga
Lithuania
Historical Landscapes
The Curonian Spit
Geology of the Curonian Spit
Poland
Towns
Gdańsk / Danzig
The History of Mediaeval Gdańsk
Mediaeval and Renaissance Gdańsk
Kraków
The Old Town
Jewish Kraków - Kazimierz and the Ghetto
Wrocław / Breslau
The Botanical Garden
The Wrocław Dwarfs
Castles
Ogrodzieniec Castle
A Virtual Tour
From the First Castle to the Boner Family
Czechia
Towns
Cheb / Eger
Pretty Houses in the Old Town
Karlovy Vary / Karlsbad
Brief History of the Town
Kutná Hora
The Sedlec Ossuary
Walk through the Town, with St.Barbara's Church
Belgium
Towns
Antwerp
The Old Town
Bruges
Mediaeval Bruges
Ghent
Mediaeval Ghent
Tongeren
Roman and Mediaeval Remains
Luxembourg
Towns
Luxembourg City
A Tour of the Town
France
Towns
Strasbourg
A Tour of the Town
Hiking Tours and Cruises
Germany
The Baltic Sea Coast
The Flensburg Firth
Rugia - Jasmund Peninsula and Kap Arkona
Rugia - Seaside Ressort Binz
Rugia - The Pier of Sellin
A Tour on the Wakenitz River
Harz National Park
Arboretum (Bad Grund)
Bode Valley and Rosstrappe Cliff
Ilse Valley and Ilse's Rock
Oderteich Reservoir
Rappbode Reservoir
Views from Harz mountains
Nature Park Meissner-Kaufunger Wald
Hessian Switzerland
Nature Park Solling-Vogler
Forest Pasture - Hutewald Project
The Raised Bog Mecklenbruch
Nature Park Reinhardswald
The Old Forest at the Sababurg
Thuringian Forests
Oberderdorla and Hainich National Park
Rivers and Lakes
The Danube in Spring
Edersee Reservoir
A Rainy Rhine Cruise
The Moselle
Vineyards at Saale and Unstrut
Weser River Ferry
Weser Skywalk
Wildlife
Harz Falcon Park
Ozeaneum Stralsund: The Baltic Sea Life
Ozeaneum Stralsund: The North Sea Life
Red squirrels
Seasons
Spring in the Botanical Garden Göttingen
Spring at the 'Kiessee' Lake
Spring in the Rossbach Heath (Meissner)
Memories of Summer
Summer Hiking Tours 2016
Autumn in the Meissner
Autumn at Werra and Weser
Winter at the 'Kiessee' Lake
Winter Wonderland - Views from my Balcony
United Kingdom
Mountains and Valleys
West Highland Railway
The East Coast
By Ferry to Newcastle
Highland Mountains - Inverness to John o'Groats
Some Photos from the East Coast
Scottish Sea Shores
Crossing to Mull
Mull - Craignure to Fionnphort
Pentland Firth
Castles Seen from Afar (Dunollie and Kilchurn)
Staffa
Summer Days in Oban
Summer Nights in Oban
Wild Wales - With Castles
Views of Snowdownia
Views from Castle Battlements
Wildlife
Sea Gulls
Scandinavia
The Hurtigruten-Tour / Norway
A Voyage into Winter
Along the Coast of Norway - Light and Darkness
Along the Coast of Norway - North of the Polar Circle
Norway by Train
From Oslo to Bergen
From Trondheim to Oslo
Wildlife
Bearded Seals
Dog Sledding With Huskies
Eagles and Gulls in the Trollfjord
The Baltic Sea
A Baltic Sea Cruise
The Curonian Spit in Lithuania
Beaches at the Curonian Spit
Geology of the Curonian Spit
|
|